Section 5: Bridge Rail Type Selection Guidance
Section 5: Bridge Rail Type Selection Guidance
Introduction
Introduction
This section provides guidance and considerations to aid in the selection of the bridge rail type based on test level, various categories, and aspects of the bridge.
Summary of Bridge Rails by Test Level
Summary of Bridge Rails by Test Level
Bridge rails are crash tested to various test levels. The exact parameters of these levels are presented in Chapter 2. Bridge railing group by test level is summarized in the following table.
Low speed (45 mph or less) | High Speed (above 45 mph) | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
TL-2 (car and pickup) | TL-3 (car and pickup) | TL-4 (single unit truck, car, and pickup) | TL-5 (tractor-van trailer, car, and pickup) | TL-6 (tractor-tank trailer, car, and pickup) |
T631LS | T1F | T2P / C2P | T224 | T80TT |
T411 | T1P | T222 | T80HT | |
C411 | T1W | T402 / C402 | T80SS | |
T221 / C221 | SSTR | C412 | ||
T223 / C223 | C1W | |||
T551 / T552 | ||||
T631 | ||||
T66 / C66 | ||||
T131RC | ||||
T221P |
Bridge Rail Categories
Bridge Rail Categories
Bridge rails can also be summarized by various categories, such as:
- Historic- looks like older rail types, such as picket rails (C2P), post and beam (T66 and C66), or the Texas Classic (T411 and C411).
- Aesthetic- These rails include the T1F, T1P, T1W, T411, T66, C2P, C1W, T224, and C412.
- Open- Open rails on Texas bridges enhance the bridge user's view from the bridge and often improve the appearance of the bridge. TxDOT encourages the use of open bridge railing on most bridges crossing a water feature and locations where the view would appeal to users. The cost premium of open bridge railing often may be offset by increased positive perception of the public. These rails include the T1F, T1P, T2P, T1, C2P, and C1W.
- Partially open- These rails are similar to open but have less open area. These rails include the T411, C411, T223, C223, T402, C402, and T224.
- Drainage- Rails that provide large openings near the deck. These rails include the T631, T631LS, and T223.
- Lightest- These are the rails with the least weight. The T631/T631LS are the lightest rails. Other rails under 200 lbs./lf include the T1F, T1P, T2P, and T1W.
- Narrowest- The rails that have the least width at 12 inches or less are the T631, T631LS, T221, and T222.
- Precast or rapid construction- The T221P rail is precast and is anchored by bolting thru the deck. The T631 and T631LS can be installed quickly. The T221, T222, T551, T552, SSTR, and T80SS can be slip formed which speeds up construction. The T402, C402, and T80HT can be slip formed when adhesive anchors are used.
Considerations
Considerations
Consider the following aspects of the project in the selection of a bridge railing.
- Average daily traffic and percentage of truck traffic - Higher truck traffic may warrant a higher test level.
- Type of roadway (interstate/county road, divided/undivided, one-way/two-way traffic) - Type of roadway can help determine traffic mix, type of end treatment needed, and potential long term maintenance concerns.
- What is located under or adjacent to the bridge (lower roadway, water, schools, and emergency services)? The T631 and T631 LS rail cannot be used over lower roadways.
- Posted speed at the bridge - Speeds above 45 mph require a TL-3 or higher test level rail.
- Approach roadway width, horizontal and vertical alignment, and grade - Horizontal and vertical curves can increase the potential for rail impact. Another concern is the potential for narrowing of the approach roadway at the bridge location.
- Bridge overall width, shoulder width, horizontal and vertical alignment, and grade - Horizontal and vertical curves can increase the potential for rail impact.
- Pedestrians - Pedestrians require a taller rail. Refer to Chapter 3, "Pedestrian, Bicycle, and ADA Requirements for Bridge Railing," and Appendix B, "Acceptable Placement of Bridge Railing for Vehicular and Non-vehicular Traffic" for more information.
- Drainage -
- If the bridge may overtop within the hydraulic design requirements, consider using a rail categorized for drainage.
- For drainage of the bridge slab,
- If water is allowed to drain off the bridge slab, then consider using a rail categorized for drainage or using slots in the rail. Drain slots should not be placed over railroad tracks, lower roadways, or sidewalks. For rails that are used as separator rails between traffic and pedestrians, do not use drain slots in the separator rail to reduce the potential for ponding on the sidewalk.
- If the water has to be collected, consider using a rail with a solid concrete parapet or curb.
- End treatment - Is there enough distance to install MBGF to the required lengths or will a crash cushion be needed? The T631 and T631LS rail have specific MBGF lengths needed to anchor them, as identified on the standard details. Many crash cushions require a concrete barrier to anchor to and needs to be taken into consideration.
- Maintenance - The different rail types will require different levels of repair when impacted. The T631 and T631LS will need to be replaced. Predominately steel rails similar to the T1W tend to need more extensive repairs after an impact than solid concrete rails like the T221. Maintenance concerns need to be considered but should not be the only deciding factor. Maintenance concerns should not override drainage or open rail needs and be considered along with other aspects, such as a community's desire for an aesthetic rail and the need for a historic looking rail.
For additional guidance on rail selection, contact the Bridge Division.